The end of Virgin Atlantic's 'splendid isolation'?

photo by 900hp from Flickr, licensed under CC

The proposed tie-up between British Airways and American Airlines is moving closer to getting the green light from US authorities, and as such, Virgin Atlantic President Richard Branson is apparently worrying (saying - Branson doesn't seem like the type that worries a lot) that his airline might have to find a partner in response.

He's no doubt speaking in response to the continuing trend of consolidation in Europe. Air France and KLM have been merged for six years now, and the Lufthansa Empire has expanded its reach into Belgium (Brussels Airlines) and the UK (bmi) in addition to Austria (Austrian Airlines) and Switzerland (Swiss). Closer to Virgin Atlantic's home turf, British Airways and Iberia have already announced an intention to merge, and it's the prospect of a three-way combination between BA (Virgin's longtime archrival), Iberia and American that has been giving Branson the most grief.

He's been outspoken against the BA-AA deal for quite some time, but it seems now as though he's come to terms with its apparent inevitability - and what that means for his airline in terms of survival. Virgin Atlantic has remained fiercely independent for its entire existence (although Singapore Airlines owns 49% of the airline, the maximum amount allowed), and while it has codeshare agreements with a handful of airlines, it has never joined an alliance. But if it wants to compete with a larger British Airways, it might need to look at finding a partner. “If it becomes impossible for us to remain an independent airline and survive, we may come to a situation where we have to consolidate," Branson said.

Naturally, this begs the question - with which carrier would Virgin Atlantic consolidate with? bmi (also known as British Midland) would appear to be the logical choice, according to Branson: “I don’t think bmi has a future as a stand-alone airline if it stays in the same shape... something will happen – the two of us would be stronger together than separate.” On the surface, this seems like a good match. bmi is a member of Star, the alliance that Virgin Atlantic seems to be on good terms with (stakeholder Singapore Airlines is also a member), and is also a rival of the dreaded British Airways. Virgin Atlantic is also strictly a long-haul carrier (much like Singapore), meaning that it loses out on some passenger traffic that would be connecting through Heathrow or Gatwick on their way to other European destinations (although codeshares do help here). bmi, on the other hand, has a few longer-haul destinations but for the most part sticks close to home. So, Virgin's long-haul network should perfectly complement bmi's short-haul - right?

Complicating things is the fact that Lufthansa now owns bmi outright, and is in the process of restructuring it - and, in the process, cutting quite a few inter-European routes. Gone are Paris, Brussels, Amsterdam - service to some of these, as well as few other cities, has been supplanted by Lufthansa-owned or operated carriers. For example, the 'bmi' flights from Heathrow to Frankfurt and Milan are operated by Lufthansa. This is all well and good for bmi, perhaps, but it makes it less attractive as a merger partner, as it wouldn't have many European routes of its own to bring to the table. And bmi wouldn't have all that much to gain from a merger, either. Virgin Atlantic has a nice long-haul vacation getaway network set up at London Gatwick, but their other long-haul service at Heathrow, while substantial, pales in comparison to that of British Airways. Its relative isolation (i.e. no alliances) also makes it less attractive as a merger partner, since bmi could ostensibly benefit from being an alliance member (as it currently is, in Star).

So while bmi might seem the obvious choice, it's not necessarily an ideal fit. But if Virgin Atlantic faces a 'merge or die' scenario, then bmi might start looking a lot more attractive.

A tidbit to ponder: according to the Times article, Singapore apparently is seeking to sell its stake in Virgin Atlantic, which might expand merger possibilities. And another interesting point about Virgin Atlantic: Branson has stated that its new strategy will be to look towards leisure travel for growth, rather than business travel. Right now, he says, the airline's business is 70% at London's Heathrow airport and 30% at Gatwick, although "this will have to start balancing out."

And Branson is still sticking to his trademark optimism. He has still promised to battle it out in court against the BA-AA deal's regulatory approval if needed - however much of a 'done deal' it already is - and he has also noted that BA's ongoing labor strife (they're "shooting themselves in the foot," he says) has only helped to benefit his airline's revenue.

26 comments:

Jason Smith said...

It will be interesting to see which carrier Branson will choose if they need to consolidate.

RSA Online said...

It will be interesting but I rather like how Virgin is independent, plus I can't see Richard Branson actually consolidating with anybody :)

Bayswater Car Rentals said...

Sir Branson came to Australia recently. The vibe he has around him is amazing. I am sure what ever he does it will be successful.

Penny Auction Bidding said...

Quite interesting to watch.

RSA Course said...

From what I know of Richard Branson he certainly wouldn't be worrying - if what I have read about him is true - he'll be lying in a hammock on his island having a conference call about what to do. If they do have to choose a partner, it would be interesting to see which way he goes.

Games Online said...

Your favourite Action Games Online
must be played on the most largest website for Games Online
must be played on http://allgamesonline.org
Huge Diversity of games and Huge games database!

Games Online said...

Your favourite Action Games Online
must be played on the most largest website for Games Online
must be played on http://allgamesonline.org
Huge Diversity of games and Huge games database!

cheap flights said...

So while BMI might seem the obvious choice, it's not necessarily an ideal fit. But if Virgin Atlantic faces a 'merge or die' scenario, then BMI might start looking a lot more attractive

RSA Certificate said...

I have such admiration for Richard Branson. He is so well respected and such a great businessman and entrepreneur. I haven't heard much about this since the article was published but you never know what will happen in the future. Thanks for the article.

Pilot Salary said...

Richard Branson has battled with BA in the past and came out victorious. I have no doubts he will do it again if his airline is threatened.

helicopter flight school said...

I agree, very interesting story. Thanks for sharing!

Commission Streamer said...

BA- AA was really goodnice post shared..
thanks

Commission Streamer said...

thanks for sharing

turbcast said...

Great post

perry7 said...

Hi there,

Very intresting relation between British airways and American airlines..........

Cheap Flights To Guatemala

Seo online said...

I think its a great post.

Medical billing company

Technology Blog

Pakistani music online

Seo services company

Seo services

Inbound Call centers

Online shopping in Pakistan

Dc Limousines

Limo in washington

Limo service in baltimore

Healthcare reviews

Bus charter dc

Php tutorials

Tutors online

Emr vendors


wireless headsets
wedding Dresses online
Seo for blogs
Medical blogs

harrywilliam said...

The choice of aircraft could have been better. Unless things have changed since.

Airline Job

Bureau said...

Hi thank you for the information. i was searching for the same thing your post is very useful to me.
Aviation Market

James5000 said...

Hi there good collection of information thanks alot...........

Anchor Text


vincton899 said...

Hi there thanks for the post.........


[url="http://www.exploretrip.com/travel-deals/cheap-flights-to-santiago-scl-3.htm" rel="dofollow"]Cheap Flights To Santiago[/url]

code promo Virgin atlantic said...

thanks for sharing, this is a Great post

Euci Miller said...

Good luck to the company that they will choose.. :) cheap flights to bangkok

Ashish Mishra said...

good thought. There is a travel agency named TripToWay that offers Pune to London Flights on discounts and other domestic and International Destinations as well.

Cubic Zirconia Hearts & Arrows Cut Stones said...

Your article is very helpful thank you very much for sharing

Largest Media said...

Modern technology should incorporate all major factor eg. speed, comfort, economy, safety too.

Axis Softech said...

super duper story!! Thank you for commenting...